Index Of The Mentalist Season 1 Top May 2026

Often overlooked, this early episode establishes Jane’s methods. A young woman is found dead with red hair dye—a signature of a serial killer Jane helped convict years earlier. The twist? The real killer is the victim’s brother. Jane’s tearoom hypnosis scene is pure magic.

: Jane whispering "Tyger, Tyger" to the fake Red John. #2 – Episode 2: "The Red Hair" Rating: 8.5/10 index of the mentalist season 1 top

Jane is temporarily blinded by an explosion, forcing him to solve a murder without sight. This episode showcases Simon Baker’s physical acting and the team’s reliance on his mind rather than his eyes. It’s a brilliant bottle episode that proves the show’s concept works even without visuals. The real killer is the victim’s brother

: Cho’s deadpan reaction: "I didn’t know rangers wrote poetry." #9 – Episode 13: "Paint It Red" Rating: 7.8/10 #2 – Episode 2: "The Red Hair" Rating: 8

: Lisbon’s reluctant admiration after Jane breaks down the killer’s psychology. #6 – Episode 1: "Pilot" Rating: 8.1/10

: Lisbon confessing, "I don’t trust happy people. Jane taught me that." #8 – Episode 5: "Redwood" Rating: 7.9/10